lunes, 1 de marzo de 2010

Psychoanalysis, Fundamentalism and Colonialism By: Clynton R. López Flores clyntonr@ufm.edu

This text was produced thanks to the visit of Juan Fernando Perez to NEL Guatemala.

Recently J. A. Miller has stated the new policy for the AMP (Asosiación Mundial de Psicoanalisis, by its initials in Spanish), that new policy intends to revitalize the association in order to produce new knowledge about the unconsciousness. The elected way of revitalized the association is simple, and can be summarized to no-Lacanian readers as follow: Analysts be more opening minded! And the association must recognize the knowledge regarding the unconsciousness that is in possession of the analyzed people. Is their turn to speak out!

This new policy by J.A. Miller has had consequences already. The conclaves of the AMP have been opened to no members and some people have accepted the suggestion to produce new knowledge in a very definitive way, making themselves trying to produce new knowledge about the unconsciousness.

In this process of self questioning of the association I have had a really interesting experience that relates the ideas of psychoanalysis, fundamentalism, colonialism and my own understanding (I prefer understanding than knowledge, the influence of Heidegger is not just an imaginary one) about the unconsciousness.

Guatemala has a large tradition of being colonized by different fundaments or ultimate’s truths. For example when Pedro de Alvarado, the Spanish colonizer, first came to conquest Guatemala he brought not only the idea of moral superiority of Christians, but, the seed of what Heidegger calls Ge-stell[1]. Making this simple Ge-stell could be understood as the way of revealing of modern technology. This way of unconcealment (of Being) is a way of understanding: the technological enfraimming that creates an horizon of meaning where everything and everybody is a resource. But, not even a resource in itself, only, as an instrument of the rationality of production in an endless metonymy. The ultimate expression of this horizon of meaning (or to put it in heideggerian terms world) is what Lyotard has called the Capitalism Techno-science[2]. What do these two ideas (Christianism and Ge-stell) have in common? What they share is the common belief in one ultimate ground or fundament. This idea is what Heidegger, and more clearly, Derrida has stated as western metaphysics[3]. The issue of metaphysics is a simple one: metaphysics pretends to reduce, categorize the whole phenomenon of reality (understanding reality in a very broad sense including what Husserl calls the world of living, the world of human values) in a simple single discourse that assures with certainty the reproduction of reality in itself. That discourse (metaphysics) that reproduces reality has had, previously to be articulated, grasped the ultimate ground (talpetate in Guatemalan expression) where reality rest. This ultimate ground could be well expressed as God, materialistic development, or something as simple as sport team. In Heidegger’s philosophy the being-into-death (the Da-sein), with all the implications[4] that this concept has about the dissolution of the Cartesian and Kantian subject, represent the beginning of the end of metaphysics. (Freud and the idea of unconsciousness, Nietzsche and the superhuman are high-ways to these implications too). But, the idea of Heidegger is that our last fundament or the ultimate reality where our reality rest is our own finitude. Consequently, all ideas of transcendence reality (God, Human Nature, Laws of economic development, cultural superiority base on any idea as race superiority) are pure metaphysic!

Well, enough of introductions. The way I have understanding and living the analytical experience has been based on what many call Lacanian Psychoanalysis, this is: as the anticipation of my own death, feeling the anguish of my own finitude, understanding the senseless of vanity (which is usually imaginary) and finally, by the resoluteness as my existentialist project. The influence of Heidegger, at least, in the Lacan I, I think it is obvious.

What practical signifiers have made me understand the idea of not-fundament? I remember one of the interventions of my Lacanian-oriented analyst that I remember as definitive one: (referring to my father) “Que no queres un hombre que te este limpiando el culo todo el tiempo”. (You do not want a man that will be cleaning your ass all the time). This intervention was, I remember, about deciding important things in my life as choosing if I would be engaged to my religion or any religion at all[5]. I needed by that time (It was around the first year of my analysis) something, or someone that legalize, or back-up my decisions, I was looking for understanding. J. P. Sartre would have said: Nausea. I felt Nausea with that intervention. Eventually I realized that it was my life, my choice and my responsibility. Some unintended consequences of that intervention were that not only me, but every single person, every single culture has his own way of solving the problem of what to do with his desire in that brief moment between birth and death. If we put together ideas of Heidegger, Vattimo, and Freud and some Lacanian analysis and mix them up one find one singular Clynton! Re- signified by the new interpretation of the signifiers that made me up before…. (I cannot forget Economics!)

But, what for God´s sake has all this to do with colonialism? In one of the last meetings of the NEL in Guatemala (New Lacanian School, by its initials in Spanish), one foreigner was talking in a very disrespectful manner about Guatemalan culture[6]. Of course, a very specific aspect of it: our machismo! He describe as primitive this way of living. Probably what bothered me a lot was the superiority (metaphysics superiority) that he used; but and also the complacent attitude of my Guatemalan partners. I replied arguing that his attitude criticizing us was very similar to the colonialism rhetoric. I claim that may be he doesn’t understand a cultural difference, and that is up to each culture and subjects of that culture to decide their own way of living? He replied: “Sometimes is good to be intolerant about cultural difference!”

What I have seen, with some horror, is that in many ways psychoanalysis is taken as new and true fundamentalism! As the ultimate truth! What this foreign person forgets, is that, in psychoanalysis what you learned in the divan is truth, but not the Truth. It is only a small truth about our unconsciousness and has limits in its general application. These kinds of truths that psychoanalysis produces are limited and finite just as our understanding and existence! I like to understand psychoanalysis not as an ideology, but as a practice open to new understanding of our unconsciousness. I remember suddenly something: Slavoj Zizek writes in the La Suspension Political de la Ética, that the fundamentalist is that person who not only fantasizes, is that person who fantasized and beliefs in his own fantasy as it were truth. The non-fundamentalist keeps himself one step back from his own fantasy. (In this case the fantasy of a realm without machismo, or without differences of sexes?)

My main thesis here is simple. Is not Colonialism base on metaphysics conception of truth? And, if we are not careful enough and we convert psychoanalysis into an ultimate ground, and ultimate Truth, consequently converting it into an ideology, wouldn´t be, in that case, psychoanalysis a very sophisticated tool of colonization? And in Latin America would psychoanalysis become a tool of subjugation to “richer” countries?

This brief article is written in English just to remember all my Latin American folks that we have been suffering of colonization just enough!!

I finish this by saying to the girls that are suffering from machismo: Enjoy your symptom! (Slavoj Zizek), and to my Guatemalan folks: What are we Guatemalans doing to look desperate to be colonized? Even to people from a very well established colony of the current empire (The foreign person was Colombian). Time for us Guatemalans to think about us…



[1] To further clarification about this idea on Heidegger I recommend the Reading of Question Concerning Technology first published on 1954.

[2] I am an economist then I´ve been living understanding the logic of capitalism not only as theorist but in a more fundamental way: as executive officer in a financial institution where I am piece of the capitalist machinery.

[3] For further Reading about the idea of western metaphysics one can see the essay Momentos metafisicos de occidente, available here http://paginas.ufm.edu/clyntonr

[4] The dissolution of the subject implies the end of scientific and objective knowledge as ultimate way of knowledge.

[5] I chose to have no religion at all, or my own light version of Catholicism. In fact I do really enjoy this version of Catholicism.

[6] This certainly was only my interpretation. My particular way to understand that discourse about the machismo of my country.